Jamaica issued state of emergency on Nov. 15 and reissued the declaration on Dec. 6
By Peter Aitken
Jamaica’s state of emergency may threaten its tourism industry as crime continues to increase in the country and local authorities struggle to clamp down on it.
“That is all the government is trying to do,” Jamaican Prime Minister Andrew Holness said, adding that Jamaicans “have to hide under their beds, hide their daughters, can’t go to church, and they see their sons and their boyfriends and husbands killed. That’s the reality.”
The U.S. State Department on Oct. 5 issued a level 3 travel advisory, indicating that Americans should “reconsider travel” due to an increased risk of crime in the country. The advisory noted that “violent crimes, such as home invasions, armed robberies, sexual assaults and homicides, are common” and that “sexual assaults occur frequently,” even at all-inclusive resorts.
“Local police lack the resources to respond effectively to serious criminal incidents,” the advisory stated. “Emergency services vary throughout the island, and response times may vary from U.S. standards. The homicide rate reported by the Government of Jamaica has for several years been among the highest in the Western Hemisphere.”
Jamaica appeared to acknowledge the severity of its problem by declaring a state of emergency on Nov. 15 in order to better empower authorities to deal with the crime in the capital of Kingston as well as popular tourist spots like Montego Bay, then it issued a renewed state of emergency on Dec. 6 due to increased violence and gang-related crimes.
The state of emergency has proven controversial as authorities can arrest people and search buildings without a warrant, potentially leading to police abuse, critics argue, but Holness stressed the need to crack down on the problem.
“We have some really serious criminal threats facing us, and we have to use all the powers at our disposal,” Holness said.
Tourism provides Jamaica its main source of income, accounting for as much as 29% of the country’s GDP in 2019 (pre-pandemic) according to Statista, and tied with remittances (money or goods sent back from nationals who emigrated from the country). Jamaica welcomed more than 1.5 million tourists in 2021 who spent more than $2.095 billion, according to the Caribbean Tourism Organization.
With fewer than 1.3 million stopover arrivals (longer than 24 hours for international travelers) in 2021, the U.S. represented the largest spending and best-performing market for tourists to the island.
According to David Katz, the founder and CEO of Global Security Group Inc. and a former U.S. federal agent, the combination of a U.S. travel advisory and a national state of emergency could severely hurt Jamaica’s tourism industry and endanger its economy.
An advisory alone can harm the economy and is “not generally well received by the subject of the advisory,” Katz told Fox News Digital. “In years past, the State Department, depending on the political situation, was sometimes reluctant to even issue a warning.”
People will go out of their way to ignore the travel warning, according to Katz, but Jamaica’s state of emergency is likely to have a bigger impact and draw more attention.
For Katz, Jamaica declaring “we have a state of emergency, we are completely out of control” would have an effect.
Katz also emphasized the need for increased attention to travel safety by bringing up the situation in Peru, where hundreds of American tourists are unable to leave the country as a result of the demonstrations that have been going on for the past week since Pedro Castillo’s removal from his position as president. At least 200 Americans are still stuck at Machu Picchu with no way to even get back to their hotels, much less leave for home, as a result of protesters blocking trains, roads, and runways.
“I ask people all the time: Where are you going to go to? Do they have a professional fire department? What are the traffic laws? What are the statistics for fatal traffic accidents?” Katz said, adding that “statistically, the greatest number of Americans who are either seriously injured or killed overseas [is] as a result of traffic accidents.”
“So, you know, you want to look at these things … you always need to understand some basics: you need places to stay, you need a way in and way out, you need medical – does your medical insurance cover you when you cross the border?”
“We would recommend in our practice: defer all non-essential travel unless there was something really, really critically necessary about the trip. Put it off,” Katz said.
A request for comment from Jamaica’s foreign ministry and tourism board were not immediately returned.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.